_community   discussion-forums

Families Discussion Forums

Reply
 
Thread Tools    Search this Thread    Display Modes   
  #1  
Old 09-25-2008, 07:01 PM
livinginohio
Family Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2008
Posts: 2
Default Sister's family as roommates

Okay, so I need some opinions. My sister met her husband just after turning 20 and had thier first child before they got married. Living life has always been a struggle for them. They would have momentary spans of independent living, but have spent much of the past ten years living with our parents, his parents, and most recently (and still) me, the older sister.
Jan '06 was one of those off-times for them, behind in rent, behind in electric, etc.. Not due to lack of income, but lack of responsibility and maturity. With three children in the picture at this point, I thought I would offer to help. Not being able to offer financial assistance, I offered them a place to live in my home since I lived alone. 1900 sq ft, 3 bedroom 2 1/2 bath home. Yes you did the math right, I was one bedroom short. I spent that year's bonus putting a room (a nice one at that in my basement).
Of course they had no reliable vehicle, the one they had on it's last leg. So I put my credit on the line and financed a new one for them. To find out the very next day my sister was pregnant. Well a car would do just fine for a family of five, but not at all for six. So I took the hit and traded in the BRAND NEW car and got a mini-van. (they make the payments and have never missed a one)
This year they paid rent in advance with their tax returns, leaving them a sizable chunk of 'disposable' income every month. And that's exactly how it was treated, as disposable instead of a mechanism to independence and getting back out on their own.
Life the past two years has been pretty good. Of course we have our difference of opinions on things, mostly cleaning related, but nothing overly significant. I don't really mind them living here. The kids are fun to have around, most of the time , as kids will be kids, and if you have some, you know what I mean.
And then suddenly, we have a twist. My 30 yr old sister has become pretty good friends with her 22 yr old coworker, who is currently living at home with her parents. So out little cohesive, hermit-live existance comes to an end. My sister has her over most nights of the week, from just after dinner until 10,11, 12, 1 o'clock at night.
I've expressed my opinion to my sister that I do not want company over at my house every night, a couple nights is fne, but that's all ... and not past 10 o'clock. And no, I do not have a double standard. I am quite the hermit. I go to work and come hme, don't have any of my own company over, ever. I like it that way.
She thinks I am being unfair because they 'don't bother me' when she's here. Which is true I suppose, but to me, bother or not is irrelevant. However ... when the friend is here, my sister's children now become a bother to her and day-to-day repsonsiblities are also in the way.
My sister will leave clean laundry in baskets for days because she 'doesn't have time' to put it away. The kids rooms aren't picked up because 'she didn't know they were messy'.
I am at the point of frustration and we have had two not so friendly discussions as of late.
So ... opinions and questions please, I need advice. I dont think I am being unreasonable, she thinks I am.
I have two basic asks .. (from day 1) put things back where they belong/clean up after yourself and (new request) company only 2-3 nights a week and not past 10.
Oh sorry, I forgot to mention that the friend brings a 6-pack over almost every time she comes to visit and drinks it here, which I have also asked to be stopped. I am not a proponent of daily drinking just for the sake of it. And most visits she either brings fast food for her dinner or has pizza delivered here (to MY house), it just gets my goard for some reason ... eat at home, THEN come over if you must.
okay , go...
  #2  
Old 09-25-2008, 07:56 PM
Labhaoise's Avatar
Labhaoise
Family Member
 
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 899
hmmm, not sure what advice I can give you... but you are the home owner right? When they moved in did they sign a lease or any sort of formal document in regards to the way in which rent was to be paid and all other expectations? If not, maybe it might be a bit too late to set something up now, Im not sure.

But they should be respecting and following your requests, as you have really helped them out of a tight spot and for some time now I gather. Good on you for doing that too!
I think maybe sitting down and calmly discussing these issues might work. My dad always says to me (I'm 18 and still live at home) "when your in your own house you can do what you like, until then it's my house and you will have to do what we request"--thats in regards to who comes over, how I act etc. For example my folks really arent crazy about alcohol, so I don't drink at home.

HTH all the best with whatever you decide!
__________________


  #3  
Old 09-25-2008, 10:04 PM
marylr's Avatar
marylr
Family Member
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 567
You have to look at this from a legal point of virw- if the friend gets into a car accident on the way home after drinking at your home, you may be held liable.
__________________
Mary's Wish List

  #4  
Old 09-25-2008, 11:11 PM
Tracey with 6
Family Member
 
Join Date: Feb 2006
Posts: 2,357
I htink you ahve been very understanding and It's abouttime they understood this, there are very few people who get this help from family or freionds, maybe she should try it on her own again, or learn to live and let live, which in your house means your rules.
__________________



  #5  
Old 09-27-2008, 07:44 AM
QueenAngie's Avatar
QueenAngie
Sr. Moderator
 
Join Date: Jul 2006
Posts: 8,026
Welcome to the board!

Your home, your rules.

Am also wondering if you are jealous of this new friend that your sister has?

Bottom line, your home, your rules.
__________________
Photobucket


Hello from Central Illinois, USA!
We are Peanut Butter & Jelly =
Sandwich Generation.
28th Wedding Anniv in 2009.
Blessed w/ 2 sons: age 23 & 20 in college & my elderly father 87, our 'older kid.'
  #6  
Old 09-27-2008, 08:56 AM
livinginohio
Family Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2008
Posts: 2
Thank you all for reading my huge vent. I appreciate the feedback. In my gut I didn't think I was wrong, but it's nice to get confirmations.
I've been researching the liability thing, and I think I'm clear there. It 'would' fall under 'social host liability'. But in this case, I am not providing the alcohol. But I might dig into that more.
Am I jealous? I don't think so, but maybe deep down I might be. When the friend is here, then that is the end all be all, so maybe. But even if that was the case, I don't think I am being unreasonable. No guests more than three nights a week and not past 10 on a work/school night.
thanks again.

Reply

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes
Signup for our free community and join the conversation with 450,385 registered users active members!
Username
Password
Email
Birth Date
Gender Female Male
Agree to terms of use.
Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | Unsubscribe | Blog For Us! | Be a Moderator! | Advertise with Us | Help